Welcome To El Maguey Mexican Restaurant


“Always treated well and service is top notch with attentive waiters. The food is the best I’ve ever had and I’ve had a lot of Authentic Mexican.  Try the Sol Quesadillas. Also one of my favorites is Pineapple Fajitas.”

Jon L.


“This place is a hidden Gem…..! definitely my favorite Mexican restaurant in Salem and reasonably priced. I go there for business lunches. Easy parking, friendly staff.”

Will L.


Great food! Great Atmosphere! Great Service!! What more can I say? We stopped there on our way home from vacation, we had 3 adults and 6 children in our party, and EVERYONE one satisfied! Not an easy task!”

Megan J.


104 E Market St,

Salem, IN


(812) 883-0098

El Maguey Voted Top 10 Mexican Restaurant In Indiana..!

Voted Best Mexican Food

EL Maguey Mexican Restaurant Customer Review

Do You Serve Take Out Food?

Yes, we serve take out food. Please check out our Menu here. At the moment we do not deliver.

Is Your Restaurant Kid Friendly?

We welcome families and we love children. We serve a special menu for kids. We also have outdoor patio seating.

Do You Serve Alcohol?

Yes, we serve Alcohol Click here for our menu where you will find our range of Beers, Wines, Cocktails and Signature Margaritas.

Do You Have Parking?

Yes, we are situated on the square in the center of Salem, opposite the court house, there is plenty of free on-street parking.

Do You Serve Vegetarian Food?

Yes, we have a large selection of vegetarian dishes, see our menu or ask the wait staff.